America vs Europe: The Free Speech Fight. Episode 664

On this week’s episode, Niall is joined by social commentator Karl Deeter for a provocative discussion about free speech, censorship, and who really gets to decide the limits of public debate.

The conversation centres on reports that the US has developed a new portal — freedom.gov — designed to allow users, including Europeans, to access content blocked under national or EU laws, including material deemed hate speech or linked to extremism. The move comes amid growing tension between the Trump administration and the European Commission over Europe’s tightening regulation of big tech platforms.

With investigations into companies like X and Meta, and increasing enforcement of hate speech and disinformation rules across the EU, the debate over who controls online speech is intensifying. At the same time, critics argue that speech laws in Europe are becoming more restrictive — while supporters say they are necessary to protect democracy and public safety.

So where is the line?

Are our speech limits changing?
Do you feel more cautious about what you say publicly — or post online?
Are people self-censoring for fear of being cancelled, fined, or even arrested?
And should America be interfering in Europe’s laws at all?

Niall and Karl explore whether this is a battle for freedom of expression — or a geopolitical power struggle dressed up as one.

We want to hear from you.

Has the space for open debate shrunk?
Do you think free speech is under threat — or properly regulated?
And should the US have any role in challenging Euro